Google Blogoscoped

Forum

Google Does NOT 'Non Well-formed' Penalize Web Pages

Search-Engines-Web.com [PersonRank 10]

Sunday, November 11, 2007
16 years ago2,581 views


There have been theories on Seo Blogs and forums that Google ranks higher Well-formed, Validated pages with no syntax errors.

The actually policy is revealed here:

At a search engine, you have to write your code to process all that randomness and return the best documents. By the way, that’s why we don’t penalize sites if they have syntax errors or don’t validate — sometimes the best document isn’t well-formed or has a syntax error.http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/the-web-is-a-fuzz-test-patch-your-browser-and-your-web-server/

Roger Browne [PersonRank 10]

16 years ago #

You gotta wonder, when Matt misses things that should be obvious to anyone working with web documents. He writes:

> You would not believe the sort of weird, random, ill-formed
> stuff that some people put up on the web: everything from
> tables nested to infinity and beyond, to web documents with
> a filetype of exe

If you look at the search results Matt links to, you'll see that these are not "exe files put up on the web". They are simply compiled CGIs which take a query parameter to generate the HTML page.

For example, you could have a CGI that looks like this:

example.com/index.php?document=219

or you could have a CGI that looks like this:

example.com/index.exe?document=219

Neither of these is more well-formed or inherently more secure. CGI can be implemented by any interpreted script or compiled executable. Heck, my webhost even lets you write your web applications using their FORTRAN compiler!

Philipp Lenssen [PersonRank 10]

16 years ago #

A syntax error can introduce ambuigity which will then even result in ranking differences.
Let's assume the hypothetical case in which you leave a tag open:

<p><a href="...">like this</p>

Now, maybe the browser you happen to test this with will assume "when the </p> appears, probably the link should be closed". So you won't notice it immediately. However, the search engine crawler may resolve this "ambuigity" differently and dedide the rest of the page is actually a giant link... and then reacting with random other stuff (e.g. deciding it's keyword stuffing, as so many keywords are in the link).

This was just a random example (pls ignore its specifics!) but I hope it gets the general idea across that yes, invalid documents CAN affect even search engines.

Search-Engines-Web.com [PersonRank 10]

16 years ago #

* * * * * * * * * * * *** * * * * * *

HAS GOOGLE BEGUN PENALIZING DIRECTORIES NOW?????

there is another interesting post on that blog that references this article

http://sphinn.com/story/4415

If this is true – that directories have been penalized the way blogs and sites selling links without the NOFOLLOW have......

FORGET IT FRIENDS!!!!!

there will be NO other way for a small biz to competitively optimize...

So cave in, and forever by ADWORDS – which is what is behind all of this so-called SERPs cleansing.

Forum home

Advertisement

 
Blog  |  Forum     more >> Archive | Feed | Google's blogs | About
Advertisement

 

This site unofficially covers Google™ and more with some rights reserved. Join our forum!